Episode 9: Getting Medieval on the Battle of Tours


Eighteen years ago, at the beginning of the third millennium after the birth of Christ, Muslim jihadists flew planes into the Twin Towers in New York City. Was this a watershed in the clash of civilizations? You would think after eighteen years, we would know, but historians have been arguing for centuries about the meaning of the Frankish encounter with Muslim forces at the Battle of Tours-Poitiers.  Spoiler alert: The Franks won! But how was the battle remembered? Do we have Charlemagne to thank for defeating the Saracens? You know very well the story is more complicated than you have heard!

Video with subscription at Unauthorized.tv (History and Logos Channel)

References

 Texts
Events
Merovingians
Carolingians
Recommending reading
Images

Comments

  1. tjgannon@sbcglobal.netSeptember 14, 2019 at 2:27 PM

    This is an informative point of view. Most important is that the people involved were not clear on what the overall significance of this battle until long after. Before this lecture I followed Rodney Stark's "How the West Won" to understand this battle. Even Rodney admits a lack of clarity about the exact location of either battle. What I learned from Rodney is the significance of superior western technology and tactics to the Arab t&t. It is interesting that the Franks learned the shield wall from Roman tactics and had large shields that would make a wall. The Arabs had small shields and depended on foot charges and cavalry. Their horses had no stirrups so the riders had no leverage against the shield wall and were turned back. The purpose of Frankish cavalry was to hunt down the stragglers running away after the ranks were broken. They did not go past the Arab camp lest they be encircled, nor did the army pursue lest it over extend its lines.
    My main take away from Rachel and Rodney is that the Franks wanted the Arabs out of their territory. Myth and glory came later.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Episode 12: Getting Medieval on Earendel

Image
Once upon a time, the people of England had a mythology rich in symbolism and metaphor pointing to the ultimate truth. There was one story in particular which captured the imagination of poets, the story of a star that entered into time and lifted the people of the world out of darkness. The star’s name was Earendel—but what did his name mean? Who among men was so wise that he could unravel the riddle and make clear the mystery? J.R.R. Tolkien believed he knew! O come, O come, and learn the story of the star! Video with subscription at Unauthorized.tv  (History and Logos Channel) The O Antiphons of the Advent Lyrics I. “O King of the people and their hearts’ desire; O Cornerstone, who make both things one: come and save humanity whom you have fashioned from clay.”  II. “O Key of David and Sceptre of the House of Israel; you who open and no one closes; who close and no one opens: come and lead the captive sitting in darkness and the shadow of death from his prison...
Read more

Episode 10: Getting Medieval on the Emperor by the Grace of God

Image
His supporters satirize his opponents’ anxiety about the extent of his power by calling President Trump “God-Emperor,” but the taunt is only effective because Americans are not supposed to want kings, never mind emperors. And yet, how else would one define the West? Can there be civilization without hierarchy? Can there be peace without an emperor? Throughout the Middle Ages, European Christians looked to Charlemagne as the model for the emperor who would defend Christendom and bring back the glories of Rome. How much did Charlemagne himself contribute to this ideal? Would the Franks of the eighth and ninth centuries have recognized later representations of Charles as emperor and king? Video with subscription at Unauthorized.tv  (History and Logos Channel) Without an Emperor, there will be, sooner or later, no more kings. When there are no more kings, there will be, sooner or later, no more nobility. When there is no more nobility, there will be, sooner or later, no more bo...
Read more

Episode 8: Getting Medieval on Charlemagne’s Elephant

Image
Where did Charlemagne get his elephant and what does it tell us about the relationship between the Franks and the Mediterranean world that once was Rome? The answer may surprise you—it certainly surprised the Danes! Without Islam, the Frankish empire would probably never have existed, and Charlemagne, without Muhammed, is inconceivable. —Henri Pirenne  Video with subscription at Unauthorized.tv  (History and Logos Channel).  See also my lectures on medieval history for  the Charlemagne Institute . References Text  Reliquary of Charlemagne, 14th century Aachen Cathedral Treasury Einhard, Life of Charles , trans. Samuel Epes Turner (1880) Chapter 16 , on Charlemagne’s foreign relations People—and elephant Henri Pirenne (1862-1935) Charlemagne (reigned 768-814) Harun al-Rashid (reigned 786-809) Abul-Abbas (d. 810) Pirenne’s disappearances   Papyrus Wines of Gaza Oil from Africa Spices Silk Gold coinage Elephants, ...
Read more